Skip to content
Know Your Rights
Source: Gotham Schools
Subject: Education Justice
Type: Media Coverage

Live Blogging – The City Council Capital Plan Hearing, Sort Of

I spent the
afternoon at the City Council’s hearing on the School Construction Authority’s
proposed capital plan, and I tried to post updates as they happened.
Unfortunately, the wireless at City Hall wasn’t cooperating, so here are some
highlights of the hearing, just a few hours after it ended.

1:20 p.m.
Education Committee chair Robert Jackson led off right away with the elephant
in the room: the economy. He said the city is facing "very difficult economic
times" and noted that the mayor has requested that all city agencies reduce
their capital requests by 20 percent. Economic conditions didn’t stop Jackson from saying that
the council wants to "take [the SCA] to task for unresolved problems and
exaggerated claims." In particular, he pointed to the authority’s claim that
the current capital plan is the largest in the city’s history, noting that many
more seats were created in the early years of the 20th century. Jackson also noted the
Campaign for a Better Capital Plan’s finding that more school seats were added
in the last six years of the Giuliani administration than in the first six
year’s of Bloomberg’s.

1:30 p.m.
Kathleen Grimm, the DOE’s deputy chancellor for administration, drew some
laughter when she read from her prepared testimony about the DOE’s recent
"capital accomplishments" the departments’s oft-repeated claim that the current
capital plan, which runs through the end of June 2009, is the largest in its
history. She said in the future she’ll be specifying that it’s the largest plan
in SCA’s history, not the DOE’s. The state created SCA in 1988.

1:45 p.m.
SCA head Sharon
Greenberger walked council members through a Power Point presentation about the
proposed capital plan. She noted that the SCA did incorporate a plan for class
size reduction into its calculations — but the reduction was to 28 students in
grades 4-8 and 30 in high school, not 23 as the state Contracts for Excellence
requires for those grades.

1:55 p.m.
The economy rears its ugly head again. Jamie Smarr, head of the DOE’s Education
Construction Fund, said he’s not focusing right now on developing new
public-private partnerships to create more school seats. "My principal job is
to keep the projects that we do have going through [the economic] contraction,"
he said. Those projects, all of which are located in Manhattan’s District 2, include the PS
59/High School for Art and Design building whose plans were released in

2:10 p.m.
Picking up on what’s clearly becoming a theme, Jackson and Grimm argued about
the class size targets used in developing the capital plan. Jackson asked when the DOE and SCA will adopt
the class size targets required by the state. Grimm’s answer: Never. "When we
look at our targets and factor in the actual utilization of these classrooms …
we really do arrive on a citywide level at targets that are 20 or 21," she
said. In other words, Grimm said, classes can get down to the size the state
requires even if the city doesn’t build more school seats than it already plans
to. Jackson
didn’t buy Grimm’s logic. "Those numbers are not acceptable to me as the chair,
to advocates, or to parents," he said. "What they really mean is that children
will be in overcrowded classrooms."

2:20 p.m.
Has anyone ever made a joke about Kathleen Grimm’s name? She certainly lived up
to it just now when she responded to a question about school construction
costs. "It is a very expensive proposition," Grimm answered. "That’s why we are
trying to use every tool we have to address overcrowding in our schools, so we
don’t have to rely on capital dollars. We don’t have enough."

2:25 p.m. Jackson has turned the
floor over to his colleagues on the council. Most of them are asking about
overcrowding issues in their own districts. Judging from their questions, if
overcrowding is only a local problem, as the DOE says it is, it seems to affect
a lot of localities.

2:40 p.m.
It’s return of the light bulbs here in the Council Chambers! Last week during a
hearing on the DOE’s proposed budget reductions, Council Member Lew Fidler said
the city should cut costs by switching to energy-efficient light bulbs. Now
Fidler said the situation is worse than just wasteful: Many schools don’t even
have the fixtures to accept energy-efficient bulbs. Grimm said the current plan
provided for fixture modernization but that the initiative had been cut back.

3:05 p.m.
The subject has turned to Transportable Classroom Units, otherwise known as
trailers. In the current capital plan, the city said it planned to removed all
TCUs by 2012. But the proposed plan calls for removing trailers on an ad hoc
basis only. Fidler said the change amounts to "waffling" by the DOE and SCA.
But Grimm said the agencies are only responding to what principals want. "No
TCU will need to be used for classroom space when the projects are completed,"
she said. "But if a principal wants to keep them, and we say they’re safe,
we’re not going to stop them."

3:20 p.m.
Randi Weingarten is in the house, offering testimony that she said is
influenced as much by her new role as the head of the national teachers union,
the American Federation of Teachers, as by her long-term experience in New
York. She said the proposed capital plan "thinks small" and could hold New York City back if
federal funds become available to stimulate local economies. I’ll have more on
this later.

testimony received a full-on round of applause in the usually staid chamber.
One person who didn’t clap, but who wished he could have: Fidler, who said if
it weren’t for the rules that bar council members from applauding, he would
have been on his feet.

also joined the list of people testifying that they are concerned about the
SCA’s class size targets. The SCA’s planning "does seem to take aim" at the
state’s class size goals, she said.

3:30 p.m.:
The only actual New York City
public school student in the room has taken the stand. Robert Moore, a
16-year-old student who attends the Bushwick
School for Social
Justice, testified on behalf of Make the Road New York, a community organization. He said
his analysis showed that there aren’t enough ninth-grade seats in Bushwick to
hold all of the neighborhood’s graduating eighth graders. "All students should
have a choice to go to school in their community," Moore said.

3:35 p.m.
Leonie Haimson, the tireless advocate for smaller class sizes and one of the
authors of the Campaign for A Better Capital report, could only address a
handful of the issues outlined on her prepared testimony during her allotted
time, but that was enough to for her to run through a litany of problems with
the capital plan’s methodology, assumptions, and conclusions. She said the DOE
and SCA are perpetrating "a huge deception" when they say overcrowding is
merely a local problem, citing a survey her organization, Class Size Matters,
conducted earlier this year that found that 86 percent of principals say large
classes at their schools prevent them from providing a quality of education. Robert
Jackson funded that survey.

Asked how
much it would cost the city to reduce class sizes to the level CFE requires,
Haimson said the answer — many billions of dollars — sounds "very scary." But
she said there are a number of ways to find the funds, from increasing the
DOE’s share of the city’s capital spending from 13.8 to 20 percent (in keeping
with its historical share) to halving the projected increase in charter school

And about
the Grimm’s explanation of why schools can still have small classes without the
DOE and SCA reducing class size targets, Haimson said, "It makes no sense if
you read it [in the capital plan] and it made no sense to me today."

3:50 p.m.
The tail end of this hearing reminds me of how many people have put in long hours
trying to crack the problem of overcrowding. Dan Golub, the land use specialist
at the Manhattan Borough President’s office, described his office’s two recent
reports about how school construction isn’t keeping pace with residential
construction. And he emphasized that the economic downturn shouldn’t stop new
construction, as scary as it is. "We can’t plan for just the current economic
situation," he said.

4 p.m.
There are a few people still hanging around to testify, but most council and
audience members have left. I don’t blame them — this has been a bummer of a
hearing, with testimony alternating between financial defeatism and complaints
that the DOE and SCA aren’t planning to build as many schools as the city